Ontology Version: 3.1.0

cacontology-synthesis-shapes:RecommendationEvidenceAlignmentShape leaf node


URI

https://cacontology.projectvic.org/synthesis/shapes#RecommendationEvidenceAlignmentShape

Label

Recommendation Evidence Alignment Shape

Targets (1)

Property Constraints (1)

Focus nodes of this shape (cacontology-synthesis:Recommendation) can have the following properties:

PROPERTY DESCRIPTION MIN MAX VALUE TYPE OTHER CONSTRAINTS
cacontology-synthesis:supportedByEvidencePointer Links a claim (or other assertion-like node) to the text evidence pointer supporting it.
sh:message Recommendation must link to at least one TextEvidencePointer.
1 * cacontology-synthesis:TextEvidencePointer
sh:severity sh:Violation

Implementation

@prefix cacontology-synthesis: <https://cacontology.projectvic.org/synthesis#> .
@prefix cacontology-synthesis-shapes: <https://cacontology.projectvic.org/synthesis/shapes#> .
@prefix rdfs: <http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#> .
@prefix sh: <http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#> .
@prefix xsd: <http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#> .
cacontology-synthesis-shapes:RecommendationEvidenceAlignmentShape a sh:NodeShape ;
    rdfs:label "Recommendation Evidence Alignment Shape"@en ;
    sh:property [ sh:class cacontology-synthesis:TextEvidencePointer ;
            sh:message "Recommendation must link to at least one TextEvidencePointer."@en ;
            sh:minCount 1 ;
            sh:path cacontology-synthesis:supportedByEvidencePointer ;
            sh:severity sh:Violation ] ;
    sh:sparql [ sh:message "Recommendation evidence quote should include the corresponding 'Recommendation N:' marker."@en ;
            sh:select """
            SELECT $this
            WHERE {
              $this <https://cacontology.projectvic.org/synthesis#recommendationNumber> ?n ;
                    <https://cacontology.projectvic.org/synthesis#supportedByEvidencePointer> ?ep .
              ?ep <https://cacontology.projectvic.org/synthesis#exactQuote> ?q .
              BIND(CONCAT("recommendation ", STR(?n), ":") AS ?needle)
              FILTER (!CONTAINS(LCASE(STR(?q)), ?needle))
            }
        """ ;
            sh:severity sh:Warning ] ;
    sh:targetClass cacontology-synthesis:Recommendation .