CAC Partnerships SHACL Shapes with gUFO Integration
SHACL shapes for validating public-private partnerships with comprehensive gUFO foundational ontology integration for enhanced semantic precision and validation capabilities.
Partnership Organization Type Validation Shape
Validates gUFO Organization type consistency for partnerships.
Partnership must be typed as gUFO Organization.
Partnership class should extend gUFO Organization.
Cooperation Event Type Validation Shape
Validates gUFO Event type consistency for cooperation events.
Technology cooperation must be typed as gUFO Event.
Cooperation events must be properly typed as gUFO Event and extend UCO Action.
SELECT $this WHERE { $this rdf:type gufo:Event . FILTER NOT EXISTS { $this rdf:type ?eventClass . ?eventClass rdfs:subClassOf* uco-action:Action . } }
Partnership Phase Type Validation Shape
Validates gUFO Phase type consistency for partnership phases.
Partnership phases must be properly typed as gUFO Phase and extend partnership classes.
SELECT $this WHERE { $this rdf:type gufo:Phase . FILTER NOT EXISTS { $this rdf:type ?phaseClass . ?phaseClass rdfs:subClassOf* cacontology-partnerships:PublicPrivatePartnership . } }
Partner Role Type Validation Shape
Validates gUFO Role type consistency for partner roles.
Partner roles must be properly typed as gUFO Role and extend UCO Role.
SELECT $this WHERE { $this rdf:type gufo:Role . FILTER NOT EXISTS { $this rdfs:subClassOf* uco-role:Role . } }
Partnership Object Type Validation Shape
Validates gUFO Object type consistency for partnership objects.
Information sharing framework should extend gUFO Object.
Partnership Situation Type Validation Shape
Validates gUFO Situation type consistency for partnership situations.
Partnership situation should extend gUFO Situation.
Partnership Temporal Shape
Validates gUFO temporal constraints for partnerships.
Partnership may have begin point timestamp.
Partnership may have end point timestamp.
Partnership end must be after begin when both are specified (gUFO temporal constraint).
SELECT $this WHERE { $this cacontology-partnerships:hasPartnershipBeginPoint ?start ; cacontology-partnerships:hasPartnershipEndPoint ?end . FILTER (?end <= ?start) }
Cooperation Event Temporal Shape
Validates gUFO temporal constraints for cooperation events.
gUFO Events must have consistent temporal boundaries with end after start.
SELECT $this WHERE { $this gufo:hasBeginPointInXSDDateTimeStamp ?start ; gufo:hasEndPointInXSDDateTimeStamp ?end . FILTER (?end <= ?start) }
Partnership Phase Temporal Shape
Validates gUFO temporal constraints for partnership phases.
Partnership phase may have begin point timestamp.
Partnership phase may have end point timestamp.
Phase end must be after begin when both are specified.
SELECT $this WHERE { $this cacontology-partnerships:hasPhaseBeginPoint ?start ; cacontology-partnerships:hasPhaseEndPoint ?end . FILTER (?end <= ?start) }
Partner Role Temporal Shape
Validates gUFO temporal constraints for partner roles.
Partner role may have begin point timestamp.
Partner role may have end point timestamp.
Role end must be after begin when both are specified.
SELECT $this WHERE { $this cacontology-partnerships:hasRoleBeginPoint ?start ; cacontology-partnerships:hasRoleEndPoint ?end . FILTER (?end <= ?start) }
Public Private Partnership Shape
Enhanced validation shape for public-private partnership instances with gUFO quality aspects.
Partnership must have between 2 and 100 partners.
Partnership scope must be from the allowed list.
Partnership duration must be between 1 and 120 months.
Partnership must specify if formal agreement exists.
Partnership effectiveness must be from allowed values (gUFO quality aspect).
Coordination level must be from allowed values (gUFO quality aspect).
Trust level must be between 0.0 and 1.0 (gUFO quality aspect).
Collaboration intensity must be from allowed values (gUFO quality aspect).
Success rate must be between 0.0 and 1.0 (gUFO quality aspect).
Multi Stakeholder Initiative Shape
Validation shape for multi-stakeholder initiative instances.
Multi-stakeholder initiative must have between 3 and 50 partners.
Tech Industry Cooperation Shape
Validation shape for tech industry cooperation instances.
Tech industry cooperation must specify if formal agreement exists.
National Initiative Program Shape
Validation shape for national initiative program instances.
Initiative name must be between 3 and 100 characters.
National initiative must have a launch date.
Program scope must be from the allowed list.
Lead agency must be from the allowed list.
Cases processed must be between 0 and 10,000.
Project Safe Childhood Case Shape
Validation shape for Project Safe Childhood case instances.
Case label should be between 5 and 200 characters when provided.
Crowdsourcing Investigation Shape
Enhanced validation shape for crowdsourcing investigation instances with gUFO quality aspects.
Public tips received must be between 0 and 100,000.
Crowdsourcing platform must be from the allowed list.
Participation level must be from allowed values (gUFO quality aspect).
Response quality must be from allowed values (gUFO quality aspect).
Engagement effectiveness must be between 0.0 and 1.0 (gUFO quality aspect).
Object Identification Request Shape
Validation shape for object identification request instances.
Objects to identify must be between 1 and 1,000.
Identification success rate must be between 0.0 and 1.0.
Geolocation Request Shape
Validation shape for geolocation request instances.
Locations to identify must be between 1 and 500.
Community Analysis Shape
Validation shape for community analysis instances.
Volunteer hours must be between 1.0 and 10,000.0.
Information Sharing Framework Shape
Enhanced validation shape for information sharing framework instances with gUFO quality aspects.
Sharing frequency must be from the allowed list.
Sharing efficiency must be between 0.0 and 1.0 (gUFO quality aspect).
Security level must be from allowed values (gUFO quality aspect).
Data quality must be from allowed values (gUFO quality aspect).
Data Sharing Agreement Shape
Validation shape for data sharing agreement instances.
Data sharing level must be from the allowed list.
Technical Integration Shape
Validation shape for technical integration instances.
Automation level must be from the allowed list.
Hash Sharing Protocol Shape
Validation shape for hash sharing protocol instances.
Hash database size must be between 0.1 and 1,000.0 million entries.
Technology Cooperation Shape
Enhanced validation shape for technology cooperation instances with gUFO quality aspects.
Technology maturity must be from the allowed list.
Innovation level must be from allowed values (gUFO quality aspect).
Implementation speed must be from allowed values (gUFO quality aspect).
Technical reliability must be between 0.0 and 1.0 (gUFO quality aspect).
Content Detection Cooperation Shape
Validation shape for content detection cooperation instances.
Detection accuracy must be between 0.5 and 1.0.
Platform Monitoring Shape
Validation shape for platform monitoring instances.
Platforms covered must be between 1 and 1,000.
Tool Development Shape
Validation shape for tool development instances.
Development investment must be between $10,000 and $100,000,000.
Coordination Mechanism Shape
Validation shape for coordination mechanism instances.
Coordination mechanism label should be between 5 and 200 characters when provided.
Regular Meeting Shape
Validation shape for regular meeting instances.
Meeting frequency must be from the allowed list.
Emergency Coordination Shape
Validation shape for emergency coordination instances.
Emergency response time must be between 0.25 and 72.0 hours.
Joint Operation Shape
Validation shape for joint operation instances.
Operation success rate must be between 0.0 and 1.0.
Partner Role Shape
Enhanced validation shape for partner role instances with gUFO quality aspects.
Partner role label should be between 3 and 100 characters when provided.
Role effectiveness must be between 0.0 and 1.0 (gUFO quality aspect).
Capability level must be from allowed values (gUFO quality aspect).
Commitment level must be between 0.0 and 1.0 (gUFO quality aspect).
Law Enforcement Partner Shape
Validation shape for law enforcement partner instances.
Law enforcement partner label should be between 3 and 100 characters when provided.
Technology Partner Shape
Validation shape for technology partner instances.
Technology partner label should be between 3 and 100 characters when provided.
NGO Partner Shape
Validation shape for NGO partner instances.
NGO partner label should be between 3 and 100 characters when provided.
Links partnership to participating organizations
Links partner organization to their role in the partnership
Links partnership activities to coordinating organization
Links partnership to information sharing frameworks governing it
Links organization to crowdsourcing investigations they conduct
Links technology partners to development projects they participate in
Links partnership activities to coordination mechanisms used
Partnership Consistency Shape
Validates consistency between partnership characteristics and participating organizations.
Partnership must include at least the minimum number of partners specified in partnerCount.
SELECT $this WHERE { $this cacontology-partnerships:partnerCount ?count . { SELECT $this (COUNT(?partner) AS ?actualCount) WHERE { $this cacontology-partnerships:includesPartner ?partner . } GROUP BY $this } FILTER (?actualCount < ?count) }
Tech Cooperation Validity Shape
Validates that tech industry cooperation includes at least one technology partner.
Tech industry cooperation must include at least one technology partner.
SELECT $this WHERE { $this a cacontology-partnerships:TechIndustryCooperation . FILTER NOT EXISTS { $this cacontology-partnerships:includesPartner ?org . ?org cacontology-partnerships:hasRole cacontology-partnerships:TechnologyPartner . } }
Crowdsourcing Effectiveness Shape
Validates crowdsourcing effectiveness metrics.
Object identification requests with high success rates should have received public tips.
SELECT $this WHERE { $this cacontology-partnerships:identificationSuccessRate ?rate . FILTER (?rate > 0.5) FILTER NOT EXISTS { ?investigation cacontology-partnerships:generatesRequests $this ; cacontology-partnerships:publicTipsReceived ?tips . FILTER (?tips > 0) } }
Data Quality Shape
Validates data quality for partnership instances.
Partnership label should be between 5 and 200 characters when provided.
Partnership comment should be between 10 and 1000 characters when provided.
National Initiative Data Quality Shape
Validates data quality for national initiative program instances.
National initiative programs should have realistic case processing numbers relative to their duration.
SELECT $this WHERE { $this cacontology-partnerships:casesProcessed ?cases ; cacontology-partnerships:launchedDate ?launched . BIND (NOW() AS ?now) BIND ((?now - ?launched) / (365.25 * 24 * 60 * 60) AS ?yearsActive) BIND (?cases / ?yearsActive AS ?casesPerYear) FILTER (?casesPerYear > 5000) }
Partnership Participation Shape
Validates gUFO participation constraints for partnerships.
Partnership must have at least 2 participating organizations (gUFO participation constraint).
SELECT $this WHERE { $this rdf:type cacontology-partnerships:PublicPrivatePartnership . { SELECT $this (COUNT(DISTINCT ?partner) AS ?partnerCount) WHERE { $this cacontology-partnerships:includesPartner ?partner . } GROUP BY $this } FILTER (?partnerCount < 2) }
Tech Cooperation Participation Shape
Validates gUFO participation constraints for technology cooperation.
Tech cooperation must include at least one technology partner and one law enforcement partner (gUFO participation constraint).
SELECT $this WHERE { $this rdf:type cacontology-partnerships:TechIndustryCooperation . FILTER NOT EXISTS { $this cacontology-partnerships:includesPartner ?techOrg . ?techOrg cacontology-partnerships:hasRole ?techRole . ?techRole rdf:type cacontology-partnerships:TechnologyPartner . } || FILTER NOT EXISTS { $this cacontology-partnerships:includesPartner ?leOrg . ?leOrg cacontology-partnerships:hasRole ?leRole . ?leRole rdf:type cacontology-partnerships:LawEnforcementPartner . } }
Multi-Stakeholder Participation Shape
Validates gUFO participation constraints for multi-stakeholder initiatives.
Multi-stakeholder initiative must include at least 3 different types of partners (gUFO participation constraint).
SELECT $this WHERE { $this rdf:type cacontology-partnerships:MultiStakeholderInitiative . { SELECT $this (COUNT(DISTINCT ?roleType) AS ?roleTypeCount) WHERE { $this cacontology-partnerships:includesPartner ?partner . ?partner cacontology-partnerships:hasRole ?role . ?role rdf:type ?roleType . ?roleType rdfs:subClassOf* cacontology-partnerships:PartnerRole . } GROUP BY $this } FILTER (?roleTypeCount < 3) }
Partnership Composition Shape
Validates gUFO part-whole relationships for partnership composition.
Partnership composition must include complementary organizational capabilities (gUFO part-whole constraint).
SELECT $this WHERE { $this rdf:type cacontology-partnerships:PublicPrivatePartnership . $this cacontology-partnerships:includesPartner ?publicOrg . ?publicOrg cacontology-partnerships:hasRole ?publicRole . ?publicRole rdf:type cacontology-partnerships:LawEnforcementPartner . FILTER NOT EXISTS { $this cacontology-partnerships:includesPartner ?privateOrg . ?privateOrg cacontology-partnerships:hasRole ?privateRole . ?privateRole rdf:type ?privateRoleType . ?privateRoleType rdfs:subClassOf* cacontology-partnerships:PartnerRole . FILTER (?privateRoleType != cacontology-partnerships:LawEnforcementPartner) } }
Technology Cooperation Composition Shape
Validates gUFO part-whole relationships for technology cooperation composition.
Technology cooperation must include both technical and operational components (gUFO part-whole constraint).
SELECT $this WHERE { $this rdf:type cacontology-partnerships:TechnologyCooperation . FILTER NOT EXISTS { { ?partnership cacontology-partnerships:coordinatedThrough $this } UNION { ?framework cacontology-partnerships:enablesSharing $this } } }
Information Sharing Composition Shape
Validates gUFO part-whole relationships for information sharing composition.
Information sharing framework must be composed of technical and legal components (gUFO part-whole constraint).
SELECT $this WHERE { $this rdf:type cacontology-partnerships:InformationSharingFramework . FILTER NOT EXISTS { ?agreement rdf:type cacontology-partnerships:DataSharingAgreement . ?agreement rdfs:subClassOf* $this . } && FILTER NOT EXISTS { ?technical rdf:type cacontology-partnerships:TechnicalIntegration . ?technical rdfs:subClassOf* $this . } }
Qualified Partnership Participation Shape
Validates gUFO qualified participation situations in partnerships.
Qualified participation must involve appropriate partnership roles and organizations (gUFO qualified relation).
SELECT $this WHERE { $this rdf:type gufo:ParticipationSituation . $this gufo:participatesIn ?partnership . ?partnership rdf:type cacontology-partnerships:PublicPrivatePartnership . FILTER NOT EXISTS { ?org cacontology-partnerships:hasRole ?role . ?role rdf:type ?roleType . ?roleType rdfs:subClassOf* cacontology-partnerships:PartnerRole . } }
High Effectiveness Partnership Rule
Advanced gUFO business rule: Highly effective partnerships should have high trust and coordination levels.
Highly effective partnerships must have high trust levels and enhanced coordination (gUFO business rule).
SELECT $this WHERE { $this cacontology-partnerships:hasPartnershipEffectiveness "highly_effective" . { FILTER NOT EXISTS { $this cacontology-partnerships:hasTrustLevel ?trust . FILTER (?trust >= 0.7) } } UNION { FILTER NOT EXISTS { $this cacontology-partnerships:hasCoordinationLevel ?coord . FILTER (?coord IN ("enhanced", "comprehensive")) } } }
Technology Maturity Implementation Rule
Advanced gUFO business rule: Mature technology should have fast implementation and high reliability.
Mature technology cooperation must have fast implementation speed and high reliability (gUFO business rule).
SELECT $this WHERE { $this cacontology-partnerships:technologyMaturity "mature" . { FILTER NOT EXISTS { $this cacontology-partnerships:hasImplementationSpeed ?speed . FILTER (?speed IN ("fast", "rapid", "immediate")) } } UNION { FILTER NOT EXISTS { $this cacontology-partnerships:hasTechnicalReliability ?reliability . FILTER (?reliability >= 0.8) } } }
Crowdsourcing Effectiveness Rule
Advanced gUFO business rule: High engagement effectiveness requires high participation and response quality.
High engagement effectiveness requires high participation level and excellent response quality (gUFO business rule).
SELECT $this WHERE { $this cacontology-partnerships:hasEngagementEffectiveness ?effectiveness . FILTER (?effectiveness >= 0.8) { FILTER NOT EXISTS { $this cacontology-partnerships:hasParticipationLevel ?participation . FILTER (?participation IN ("high", "massive")) } } UNION { FILTER NOT EXISTS { $this cacontology-partnerships:hasResponseQuality ?quality . FILTER (?quality IN ("excellent", "exceptional")) } } }
Information Sharing Security Rule
Advanced gUFO business rule: High data quality requires enhanced security levels.
Excellent or verified data quality requires enhanced or high security levels (gUFO business rule).
SELECT $this WHERE { $this cacontology-partnerships:hasDataQuality ?quality . FILTER (?quality IN ("excellent", "verified")) FILTER NOT EXISTS { $this cacontology-partnerships:hasSecurityLevel ?security . FILTER (?security IN ("enhanced", "high", "maximum")) } }
Partner Role Capability Commitment Rule
Advanced gUFO business rule: High role effectiveness requires advanced capabilities and high commitment.
High role effectiveness requires advanced capabilities and high commitment levels (gUFO business rule).
SELECT $this WHERE { $this cacontology-partnerships:hasRoleEffectiveness ?effectiveness . FILTER (?effectiveness >= 0.8) { FILTER NOT EXISTS { $this cacontology-partnerships:hasCapabilityLevel ?capability . FILTER (?capability IN ("advanced", "expert")) } } UNION { FILTER NOT EXISTS { $this cacontology-partnerships:hasCommitmentLevel ?commitment . FILTER (?commitment >= 0.7) } } }
Multi-Stakeholder Complexity Rule
Advanced gUFO business rule: Multi-stakeholder initiatives with many partners need comprehensive coordination.
Multi-stakeholder initiatives with 5+ partners need comprehensive coordination level (gUFO business rule).
SELECT $this WHERE { $this rdf:type cacontology-partnerships:MultiStakeholderInitiative . { SELECT $this (COUNT(DISTINCT ?partner) AS ?partnerCount) WHERE { $this cacontology-partnerships:includesPartner ?partner . } GROUP BY $this } FILTER (?partnerCount >= 5) FILTER NOT EXISTS { $this cacontology-partnerships:hasCoordinationLevel "comprehensive" . } }
Partnership Data Quality Shape
Enhanced data quality validation for partnerships with gUFO quality consistency rules.
Partnership effectiveness and success rate should be consistent (gUFO quality consistency).
SELECT $this WHERE { $this cacontology-partnerships:hasPartnershipEffectiveness ?effectiveness ; cacontology-partnerships:hasSuccessRate ?rate . { FILTER (?effectiveness = "highly_effective" && ?rate < 0.7) } UNION { FILTER (?effectiveness = "effective" && (?rate < 0.5 || ?rate > 0.8)) } UNION { FILTER (?effectiveness = "moderate" && (?rate < 0.3 || ?rate > 0.6)) } UNION { FILTER (?effectiveness = "limited" && ?rate > 0.4) } UNION { FILTER (?effectiveness = "ineffective" && ?rate > 0.2) } }
Trust level and collaboration intensity should be correlated (gUFO quality consistency).
SELECT $this WHERE { $this cacontology-partnerships:hasTrustLevel ?trust ; cacontology-partnerships:hasCollaborationIntensity ?intensity . { FILTER (?trust >= 0.8 && ?intensity NOT IN ("intensive", "fully_integrated")) } UNION { FILTER (?trust <= 0.3 && ?intensity NOT IN ("low", "moderate")) } }